The recent cancellation of So Help Me Todd has sent shockwaves through its dedicated fanbase. While many fans are rallying for a revival, some aspects of the storyline suggest that a third season might not have been kind to every character—especially Susan. Let’s explore why the cancellation could actually be a blessing for her character.
A Quick Overview of So Help Me Todd
For those who might be new to the show, So Help Me Todd revolves around the chaotic yet endearing relationship between Todd, played by Skylar Astin, and his mother Margaret, portrayed by Marcia Gay Harden. Todd is a private investigator whose carefree lifestyle often leads to trouble, prompting his successful defense attorney mother to bring him into her law firm.
Throughout the series, Todd’s complicated relationship with his ex-girlfriend, Susan (Inga Schlingmann), plays a significant role. Their dynamic adds layers of tension and humor, but as the series progresses, it becomes evident that Susan’s journey is crucial to the overall narrative.
Susan’s Evolution: From Todd’s Ex to a Strong Professional
After her rocky relationship with Todd, Susan finds herself in a much healthier space, both personally and professionally. She’s thriving in her career at Margaret’s law firm and is engaged to Peter, a seemingly wonderful guy who supports her ambitions. However, lurking beneath her newfound happiness is a recurring desire to revisit her past with Todd.
This complicated emotional backdrop raises questions about whether Susan is genuinely happy or if she’s simply using her relationship with Peter as a placeholder while she still harbors feelings for Todd.
The Creator’s Vision for Season 3
With the show’s cancellation, creator Scott Prendergast has revealed what could have been in a third season. According to him, the plan was to have Todd navigate his feelings for Susan after a brief relationship with Judy, a character portrayed by Heather Morris. The twist? Judy would move to Thailand, leading Todd to realize he still had feelings for Susan, which would ultimately put them back together.
A Romantic Regression?
This narrative arc raises serious concerns for Susan’s character development. While Todd’s journey often leans into comedic and chaotic territory, Susan deserves a storyline that reflects her growth as a person. After all, she has come a long way from the tumultuous relationship they once shared.
Reuniting with Todd would essentially undo all the character growth Susan has achieved. Instead of moving forward, she would be drawn back into a relationship that was fraught with incompatibilities and unresolved issues.
The Better Path: A Stronger Future for Susan
In her current storyline, Susan appears to be on a trajectory that highlights her strength and independence. She is successfully navigating her career and planning a future with Peter, who embodies stability and maturity. This is the kind of relationship that aligns with her growth and reflects her character’s journey.
By bringing Todd back into the picture, the writers would risk minimizing Susan’s achievements. Rather than showcasing her as a well-rounded individual who has learned from her past, the narrative could revert to the all-too-familiar cycle of romantic drama.
The Blessing in Disguise
While many fans are disheartened by the cancellation of So Help Me Todd, it’s crucial to recognize that this may actually protect Susan’s integrity as a character. Had the show continued, there’s a real chance that Susan would have been pulled back into a tumultuous relationship with Todd, ultimately overshadowing her growth and accomplishments.
In a world where strong female characters are increasingly celebrated, Susan deserves to be one of them. Her potential to thrive in a healthy relationship, alongside her burgeoning career, is far more compelling than a recycled love story with Todd.
Conclusion: Celebrating Susan’s Strength
The cancellation of So Help Me Todd may be disappointing for fans eager to see more of Todd and his chaotic antics, but for Susan, it could be a saving grace. Instead of regressing into a relationship that didn’t serve her well, she can continue to flourish as an independent, empowered character.
While fans rally for a revival, let’s take a moment to appreciate the journey that Susan has undertaken—one that should be celebrated rather than undone.
