The recent announcement of Boston Blue, a spinoff series expanding the Blue Bloods universe, has stirred up a lot of mixed emotions among fans—especially those still reflecting on the original show’s finale. While many are excited about the prospect of continuing the legacy of Blue Bloods, there are lingering questions about the choices made in the series’ final episode. The announcement of Boston Blue has, in fact, left some fans more confused about an aspect of the Blue Bloods finale that could have been handled differently to provide a more fitting conclusion to the beloved series.
The Finale’s Mixed Reception
The Blue Bloods finale, which aired on December 13, 2024, brought the curtain down on the 14-season saga of the Reagan family, a family of law enforcement officers in New York City. The emotional weight of the finale was felt throughout the episode, with several significant moments designed to tie up the long-running stories of the Reagan family. For instance, Eddie (Vanessa Ray) and her partner Luis (Ian Quinlan) are involved in a dramatic shooting, resulting in the tragic death of Luis. Meanwhile, Erin (Bridget Moynahan) gets remarried to her ex-husband Jack (Peter Hermann), which was a significant step in her personal life. On a brighter note, Eddie and Jamie (Will Estes) reveal that they are expecting a baby, creating a sense of hope for the future of the Reagan family.
However, despite these emotional highs, many fans were left feeling that the finale was rushed and lacked the depth it needed to fully explore certain character arcs. There was a sense that the conclusion had been somewhat hasty, perhaps in an effort to wrap up multiple plot threads before the series finale. While the emotional moments were impactful, many felt that a longer, more in-depth finale could have allowed for a more satisfying resolution to the intricate relationships that fans had followed for over a decade.
CBS’s Recent Update Adds to the Confusion
In the months following the finale, CBS made a surprising move by announcing the development of Boston Blue, a spinoff that would expand the Blue Bloods universe. The spinoff will feature Donnie Wahlberg reprising his role as Detective Danny Reagan, who moves from the NYPD to the Boston Police Department (BPD). While the premise of the spinoff itself is exciting, it has left some viewers scratching their heads, especially given the emotional farewell in the original series finale. After the long buildup and heartfelt goodbyes to key characters, fans are left wondering why the story needed to continue in this direction and whether it undermines the closure the show’s finale provided.
The decision to move forward with Boston Blue—set to premiere in fall 2025—has made some fans question the need to revisit the story of Danny Reagan, especially after his journey seemed to come to a definitive end in Blue Bloods. While it’s understandable that CBS might want to capitalize on the franchise’s success, the timing of the spinoff’s announcement has left many feeling that the original series was not truly given the chance to say a proper goodbye. After all, Blue Bloods spent years building up its characters, and the finale—despite its fast pace—was meant to give fans some sense of closure, even if it did leave a few questions unanswered.
Could a Different Finale Have Provided More Closure?
Looking back at the Blue Bloods finale, many fans feel that the ending could have been handled with a bit more care and consideration. There were several moments throughout the final season that left some storylines dangling or quickly wrapped up. For instance, while Eddie’s traumatic experience was explored, the depth of her emotional journey could have been more thoroughly examined, especially as she and Jamie transition into this new chapter of their lives with the pregnancy announcement. The emotional and physical trauma Eddie experienced could have had a more significant impact on her character and relationship with Jamie.
Additionally, the suddenness of Erin’s remarriage to Jack, after all the years of will-they-won’t-they tension, left some fans feeling unsatisfied. Was this the best way to resolve their storyline after so many seasons of on-and-off romance? While the wedding was joyful, it felt like a rushed finality to what could have been a more poignant exploration of Erin’s future.
The pacing of the finale also seemed too swift given the complexity of the stories that had been developed over 14 years. Many fans had hoped that a two-hour finale would have allowed for more time to dive deeper into these character arcs and offer a more meaningful send-off for the Reagan family. Instead, the show’s rapid conclusion left some feeling that certain storylines were glossed over or forced to fit within a limited time frame.
Looking Ahead: Boston Blue and Its Impact on the Blue Bloods Legacy
The announcement of Boston Blue has raised some interesting questions about the future of the Reagan family saga. As fans eagerly anticipate the spinoff, the central issue remains: why does Danny Reagan need to move to Boston? Couldn’t his story have been completed within the confines of Blue Bloods itself? Was there truly a need for this new chapter?
While the idea of seeing Danny in a new environment, working alongside a new set of characters, is intriguing, many fans are concerned that it might detract from the emotional weight of Blue Bloods‘ final episode. The Reagan family’s story felt complete at the end of the original series, and introducing a spinoff so soon after the finale might risk undermining the emotional stakes that made the show such a success.
That being said, Boston Blue also offers a unique opportunity to explore a fresh narrative while honoring the legacy of the original show. Wahlberg’s involvement, both as an actor and an executive producer, suggests that Boston Blue will continue to focus on the core values that made Blue Bloods special—family, justice, and sacrifice. However, whether or not it will successfully live up to the expectations set by Blue Bloods remains to be seen.
Conclusion
In the wake of CBS’s Boston Blue announcement, the confusion surrounding Blue Bloods’ finale has only deepened. While the spinoff holds potential for new stories and characters, fans are left questioning whether the original series truly got the closure it deserved. With such a powerful and emotional legacy, Blue Bloods could have provided a more conclusive ending—one that would have allowed the story of the Reagan family to rest before moving on to a new chapter. Fans will have to wait and see how Boston Blue unfolds, but for now, the lingering questions about the original series’ finale remain.
